使用Rspec存根和模拟在Rails Oauth中实现100％的测试覆盖率

Question

我试图找出一种方法来存根/模拟访问令牌调用，以便为用户令牌过期时调用的方法提供覆盖。我在这个问题上阅读的指南越多，我就越感到困惑。我不想调用外部提供程序，我想确认方法报告100％覆盖率，以防开发人员修改它们并且它们工作不正确。我应该在下面的规范中添加什么才能达到100％的测试目标？

load_json_fixture('omitted_oauth')根据初始Oauth调用返回的内容引入JSON fixture。

模范关注

module OmittedOmniAuthentication
  extend ActiveSupport::Concern

  module ClassMethods
    def from_omniauth(auth)
      Rails.logger.debug auth.inspect
      where(provider: auth.provider, uid: auth.uid).first_or_create do |user|
        setup_user(user, auth)
      end
    end

    def setup_user(user, auth)
      user.provider = auth.provider
      user.uid = auth.uid
      user.email = auth.info.email
      user.customer_ids = auth.extra.raw_info.customer_ids
      user.store_token(auth.credentials)
    end
  end

  def refresh_token!
    access_token ? refresh_access_token! : false
  end

  def refresh_access_token!
    result = access_token.refresh!
    store_token(result)
    save
  rescue OAuth2::Error
    false
  end

  def settings
    @settings ||= Devise.omniauth_configs[:omitted].strategy
  end

  def strategy
    @strategy ||= OmniAuth::Strategies::Omitted.new(nil, settings.client_id, settings.client_secret, client_options: settings.client_options)
  end

  def client
    @client ||= strategy.client
  end

  def access_token
    OAuth2::AccessToken.new(client, token, refresh_token: refresh_token)
  end

  def store_token(auth_token)
    self.token = auth_token.token
    self.refresh_token = auth_token.refresh_token
    self.token_expires_at = Time.at(auth_token.expires_at).to_datetime
  end

  def token_expired?
    Time.now > token_expires_at
  end
end

Rspec Spec

RSpec.describe 'OmittedOmniAuthentication', type: :concern do
  let(:klass) { User }
  let(:user) { create(:user) }
  let(:user_oauth_json_response) do
    unfiltered_oauth_packet = load_json_fixture('omitted_oauth')
    unfiltered_oauth_packet['provider'] = unfiltered_oauth_packet['provider'].to_sym
    unfiltered_oauth_packet['uid'] = unfiltered_oauth_packet['uid'].to_i
    unfiltered_oauth_packet
  end

  before do
    OmniAuth.config.test_mode = true
    OmniAuth.config.mock_auth[:omitted] = OmniAuth::AuthHash.new(
      user_oauth_json_response,
      credentials: { token: ENV['OMITTED_CLIENT_ID'], secret: ENV['OMITTED_CLIENT_SECRET'] }
    )
  end

  describe "#from_omniauth" do
    let(:omitted_oauth){ OmniAuth.config.mock_auth[:omitted] }

    it 'returns varying oauth related data for Bigcartel OAuth response' do
      data = klass.from_omniauth(omitted_oauth)
      expect(data[:provider]).to eq(user_oauth_json_response['provider'].to_s)
      expect(data[:uid]).to eq(user_oauth_json_response['uid'].to_s)
      expect(data[:email]).to eq(user_oauth_json_response['info']['email'])
      expect(data[:customer_ids]).to eq(user_oauth_json_response['extra']['raw_info']['customer_ids'])
    end
  end

  describe '#token expired?' do
    it 'true if valid' do
      expect(user.token_expired?).to be_falsey
    end

    it 'false if expired' do
      user.token_expires_at = 10.days.ago
      expect(user.token_expired?).to be_truthy
    end
  end
end

UPDATE

  describe '#refresh_access_token!' do
    it 'false if OAuth2 Fails' do
      allow(user).to receive(:result).and_raise(OAuth2::Error)
      expect(user.refresh_access_token!).to be_falsey
    end

    it 'false if refresh fails' do
      allow(user).to receive(:access_token) { true }
      allow(user).to receive(:refresh_access_token!) { false }
      expect(user.refresh_token!).to be_falsey
    end

    it 'true if new token' do
      allow(user).to receive(:access_token) { true }
      allow(user).to receive(:refresh_access_token!) { true }
      expect(user.refresh_token!).to be_truthy
    end

    it 'true when refreshed' do
      allow(user).to receive(:access_token) { true }
      allow(user).to receive(:refresh_access_token!) { true }
      allow(user).to receive(:store_token) { true }
      allow(user).to receive(:save) { true }
      expect(user.refresh_access_token!).to be_truthy
    end
  end

=>我通过这些更新得到了94.12％

Answer 1

我不确定你可能在哪里调用外部提供程序，所以我不确定你想要什么存根/模拟。

为了让您更接近覆盖目标，请尝试为最简单的模块方法添加另一个规范：

  describe '#refresh_token!' do
    it 'is true if there is an access_token' do
      if !user.access_token?
        expect(user.refresh_token!).to be_truthy
      end
    end

    # Do you have factories or fixtures set up that can force
    # #access_token? to be falsey?
    it 'is false if there is no access_token' do
      if !user.access_token?
        expect(user.refresh_token!).to be_falsey
      end
    end

    # Maybe you want to set the falsey value for the access_token
    # as you have have for the value of token_expires_at in
    # your #token_expired? test.
    it 'is false if there is no access_token' do
      # You should be able to force the method to return a false
      # value (stub the method) with this line
      allow(user).to receive(:access_token) { false }
      expect(user.refresh_token!).to be_falsey
    end
  end

这个例子感觉有点不必要，因为你的access_token方法似乎永远不会返回false。我希望你的access_token方法总能返回一个对象，或者一个错误，所以你的refresh_token!方法永远不会遇到三元组中的错误条件。也许你应该反而拯救并返回虚假。

无论如何，我认为关键是你应该使用allow方法来存储方法，这样你就可以找到你的方法存根。希望它有所帮助。

对于refresh_access_token!，您可以通过将user.result方法存在错误来对该方法进行单元测试，而不是对refresh_access_token!方法的“成功”结果进行存根。

  describe '#refresh_access_token!' do
    it 'it returns true when refreshed' do
      # The successful control flow path for this method
      # is to save the user and return true.
      # I suppose this would happen smoothly in your tests and app.
      expect(user.refresh_access_token!).to be_truthy
    end

    it 'returns false when an OAuth2 Error is rescued' do
      # To force the case that you receive an OAuth2 Error,
      # stub the user's access_token return value with the Error
      # The refresh_access_token! method should then rescue the error
      # and cover the false return value of the method
      allow(user).to receive(:access_token) { OAuth2::Error }
      expect(user.refresh_access_token!).to be_falsey
    end
  end

Answer 2

（代表问题作者发布解决方案）。

这现在正在运作。通过以下规范调整来截断方法链，我能够成功调用true用于该方法：

  def refresh_access_token!
    result = access_token.refresh!
    store_token(result)
    save
  rescue OAuth2::Error
    false
  end

完成的规范将我推向了100％

it 'true when refreshed' do
  auth_token = OpenStruct.new(token: FFaker::Lorem.characters(50),
                              refresh_token: FFaker::Lorem.characters(50),
                              expires_at: 5.days.from_now)
  allow(user).to receive_message_chain('access_token.refresh!') { auth_token }
  expect(user.refresh_access_token!).to be_truthy
end

Stubs和Mocks可以很有趣。我从这个帖子中学到了很多东西。这是Rspec 3.4 docs on this。